Instead, all of the plot holes were actually Emma conveniently forgetting things that were relevant to the suspect of the book. For the first few chapters, I assumed that the author may just have made a mistake. Reading this immediately after finishing the preceding one, there are a lot of pretty large holes in the plot. This review is definitely affected by reading this book immediately after Never Have I Ever. I don't know if this made any sense, so in conclusion. You'd have to look for someone who has a reason to want to kill sutton, yet is super cool and fine with her/emma now. They wouldn't still be taking out their anger, playing out their revenge, on emma if they knew she was emma. However, sutton being a goner means that that person ALREADY got their revenge. The books keep focusing on possible suspects who have reason to get revenge on sutton. He's keeping her close, making her feel comfy domfy having someone know her true identity, so he can keep an eye on her Ethan hardly ever spoke to sutton, yet somehow realized that emma was emma, when suttons parents, sister, best friends, and thayer, who she has known her whole life, have no clue. Three: he had hiking gloves in his room and hello, canyon? Cliff where you can drop dead bodies and then hike on out of there? And his room is serial killer clean.įive: second biggest reason.

Two: he performs at that open mic place, right by the canyon where she was killed One: he has a pretty good reason, sutton screwed him

Two Truths and a Lie by Sara Shepard